COLUMBUS, Ohio (WCMH) -- Parents and teachers are raising concerns about violence at Columbus City Schools, with more than 850 police runs to district middle and high schools in less than three years.
“These kids are no joke. This isn't like minor disruption," an elementary school music teacher told NBC4 Investigates. "This is foul-mouthed, this is punching, this is threats, this is hitting. I don't go on the playground for fifth and sixth-grade recess. I don't do it because there's too many fights."
The elementary school teacher, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to protect her employment, said she was shocked by the violence she witnessed in the district. She said she’s seen students throw things at teachers, destroy school property, curse out others and threaten to shoot everyone at school. She said despite daily violence, she's only seen one expulsion: a third-grade student who brought a weapon to school and tried to use it.
Report: The best high schools in Ohio and nationally
Teachers are not the only ones concerned. Parent Mindy Hewitt said her 13-year-old was jumped seven times last school year, got in two fights, and instigated one after thinking a group was about to jump her. She said the year before, her daughter had been on the merit roll and rarely skipped class. Last year, Hewitt said her daughter lost more than 20 pounds due to the stress of in-school violence.
“The kids there act like they are in prison,” Hewitt said.
NBC4 Investigates combed through hundreds of police reports detailing all Columbus police calls to CCS middle and high schools. From Jan. 1, 2023, to April 18, 2025, officers responded to secondary schools 858 times.
Most of the calls were for "disturbances," which can range from calls about irate parents to assaults. Although the data is just for secondary schools, police are even involved with elementary schoolers. NBC4 Investigates obtained police video from May of elementary students brawling on a school bus and being restrained by officers.
The teacher said she believes police reports barely scratch the surface.
"I think Columbus City has made it clear that they don't like people speaking out, and they don't want the cops involved," she said. "I'm like, 'Let the cops walk through this building, let them pull out a couple of kids. Let the other kids see.'"
CCS told NBC4 Investigates it disciplined students for fighting, harassment, serious bodily harm and unwelcome sexual contact 9,103 times from August to April of the 2024-25 school year, and 11,251 the year before. The district did not make administrators available for an interview on school safety. See previous coverage of CCS sexual violence in the video player above.
Ohio State dorms told to stick with Buckeyes themes, citing DEI concerns
The district is required to submit disciplinary data to the state every year. When comparing the 2023-2024 school year -- the most recently available data -- police were called to CCS 368 times. That same year, the district reported disciplining students nearly 60,000 times.
NBC4 Investigates compared all police runs to all disciplinary activity for CCS' middle and high schools. Just three schools did not have police runs and are not included in the graph.
The elementary school teacher said she believes this data is also lacking. She said she and her colleagues are encouraged not to write up student misconduct to protect the school and principal from looking bad.
"The amount of things that are blown over because the principals are under pressure to make it all look shiny and they want to keep their jobs," the teacher said.
CCS representatives said the district is intentionally working with teachers and principals to bring down violence. The district has a detailed intervention policy that encourages de-escalation techniques like monitoring signs of distress or positive reinforcement.
CCS said de-escalation has proven effective. NBC4 Investigates spoke with Dr. Samuel Johnson Jr., the principal of Beechcroft High School. Now in his eighth year in the role, Johnson said fighting decreased 25% thanks to de-escalation techniques.
More than a nut: Ohio bills crown Buckeye as state candy, correct tree's scientific name
"We have crisis prevention, professional development, we use our counselors," Johnson said. "And again, the social emotional piece, teachers really, really sit down with the students and try to get to the root causes, and we're very proactive. Our teachers, administrators and our security have their ear to the ground."
At her elementary school, the teacher said she's seen minimal success with de-escalation. In extreme situations, teachers are permitted to physically intervene when students pose a threat to themselves or others. Although she feels it’s necessary, the elementary teacher said it was highly discouraged by her peers and superiors. She said she's seen teachers placed on leave for permitted uses of physical touch because of parent complaints or student allegations of misconduct.
She said this leaves teachers with few options, adding she has also been discouraged from sending students to school disciplinary counselors. She said she still sends them.
"I can't sit and watch 20 kids suffer because of the six in the room who are determined to make this miserable for everyone," she said.
She felt sending students to a special classroom is also not the punishment it seems. The teacher said students who go to the behavior center are given sweets and allowed to have more freedom, encouraging bad behavior.
Ohio consumers, businesses feel sting of record high beef prices
The teacher said the toll this takes on teachers is immense, and many feel like they are too close to retirement to voice concerns. She said almost every teacher she knows is on antidepressants and antianxiety medication.
"I panic when they line up at my door," she said. "After Christmas break, I think I wept that whole morning that I knew I had to go back."
The teacher NBC4 Investigates spoke with said she does not have the answer to fix the violence and disruption, but knows current practices are not working. CCS began the 2025-2026 school year this week.